On the way out of the Grand Opera House’s fortieth anniversary production of Les Miserables I bumped into noted director who said, rightly, the musical adaptation of Victor Hugo’s 1862 novel, is a big beast of a show. It’s a big ask for an amateur group, which this was, albeit highly talented and in some cases near professional members of the Belfast Operatic Company, performing with St Agnes Choral Society and Ulster Operatic Company. Overall, they did jolly well although one could argue it was curate’s eggish, good to very good in parts.
What of Valjean, the anti hero turned hero? David McCrossan was good, remorseful when considering his crimes, humble when necessary, defiant when required, tender with Cosette, the little girl he adopts when her mother is on the way out and whose wellbeing represents his redemption. The principals were all pretty good, although Fantine’s acting, except at the end, wasn’t the strongest. Inspector Javert (Boyd Rodgers) scored well in the uptight functionary role. There was comedy and the husband and wife duo, the Thenardiers, in the pub scene went ott but were good, in slightly pantomime fashion, as the abusive carers of young Cosette. Jordan Arnold was a hit with the packed audience. There was even a scene with lovely ladies, ie working girls and the prostitutes, which risqué, definitely gave their moment some welly.
In a way the highlight is Claud-Michel Schonberg’s music. There are two or three world class songs, that I found myself humming this morning. On my Own from Eponine, for example, sung while she is pining for Marius, the student revolutionary who actually loves Cosette. This was a star turn from Caroline McMichael. Also of course, I Dreamed a Dream, made even more famous if possible when Susan Boyle sang it touchingly on Britain’s Got Talent. For the rest, the chorus belted out the lovely ladies song, Look Down and so on.
There were some great deaths and this show is about love, loss, redemption, revolution, the whole damn thing. Eponine, in particular died beautifully in Marius’ arms, where she’d always wanted to be while knowing he was pining for Cosette. Marius (Aodhan Halfpenny) nearly ruined it but was good elsewhere, amorous and warlike when required. Valjean aged and died well, having gained good guy status via saving Marius’ life as well as harbouring Cosette. Fantine (Beth Tiffney) also expired well, if quickly.
The slices of politics maybe don’t always mesh so well with the personal narratives although I felt the group scenes, including aux barricades with scenes from the 1832 Paris uprising, were well directed overall. But that’s maybe a tiny flaw in this great musical, going strong for forty years which has wowed something like 150 million people since its launch. Apart from me, a Les Mis virgin.
Would I see it again? Yes, in a heartbeat to follow the Paris Uprising a bit more, enjoy the stand-out solos and relish the people power. For it’s called Let the People Sing and the people have the last word. With a standing ovation last night which was deserved for their sheer energy at tackling this legendary show.
Jane Hardy
6 comments
It was fantastic. .
Id hate to see things through your eyes .
I have seen this show, performed by professionals, in London and Edinburgh. The Belfast show was by far the best. The roles were well cast, the diction while singing was good and all performers were excellent dramatists as well as singers. The best production of Les Mis I have seen.
I agree with the first comment- it is important to note that this was an amateur cast made up of many very talented young people. Your review is extremely critical and cruel in places. Having also attended the show on opening night and having experience in both professional and amateur theatre, I can assure future audiences that every single member of the cast were superb and it was an honour to witness such a beautiful piece of theatre.
It was fabulous. I saw the same cast as the reviewer and they were all great, including Fantine and Marius. And it reached a new level every time Inspector Javert started to sing.
I think this review is rather unfortunate given that this was an amateur cast. Considering that I thought it was not only outstanding but the best amateur show I’ve ever seen